This page addresses a few important questions about tooling and the Disciplined Agile (DA) framework:
- Does DA recommend specific tools?
- What (agile) management tools support DA?
- What development tools support DA?
- What process-oriented tools explicitly support DA?
- Does scale affect tool choices?
Does DA Recommend Specific Tools?
No. The Disciplined Agile (DA) framework is orthogonal to tools. What we mean by that is the principles, practices, and techniques captured by the framework are independent of specific tools. Obviously, some practices such as continuous integration (CI), test-driven development (TDD), and continuous delivery (CD) clearly need tooling support. But for each of those practices there are many, many tools you could possibly adopt. The DA framework suggests that you adopt tools in these cases, but doesn’t specify exactly which tool to adopt nor will it ever. Tooling choices should be made by your team, often influenced by organizational guidance, not by the DA framework.
What (Agile) Management Tools Support DA?
Agile/Lean management tools include products such as Atlassian Jira, Microsoft TFS, VersionOne, LeanKit, and many others. The DA framework supports several delivery lifecycles (an agile Scrum-based lifecycle, a lean Kanban-based lifecycle, two continuous delivery lifecycles, and more). So, tools such as Jira, TFS, VersionOne, and so on that support Scrum (or Kanban, or CD) by definition also support the corresponding Disciplined Agile Delivery (DAD) lifecycle based on that method.
One issue that you may run into, particularly with the Scrum-based tools, is that they use Scrum terminology such as Sprint instead of Iteration. In these cases you have two choices – either choose to use Sprint instead of Iteration within your team (this is a common choice) or tailor the tool to use iteration. With some tools, such as VersionOne, this is very easy to do. Other tools, currently Jira for example, their architecture may not be sufficiently flexible to allow such an easy tailoring.
What Development Tools Support DA?
The Construction goals of Produce a Potentially Consumable Solution and Accelerate Value Delivery support a wide range of technical practices. Granted, technical practices are supported by many other goals, but the greatest concentration is in these two goals. The point is that because DA supports many technical practices that are common to agile – such as continuous integration (CI), test-driven development (TDD), automated regression testing, and many others – that in effect DA is supported by a host of development tools.
Possible development tool categories include, but are not limited to:
- Acceptance testing
- Build management
- Code analysis (dynamic or static)
- Code review
- Configuration management (CM)
- Continuous integration (CI)
- Schema analysis
- Test data management
- Test planning and management
- Unit/developer testing
- User interface (UI) testing
Other tool categories include:
- Collaboration tools
What Process-Oriented Tools Explicitly Support DA?
- Agility Health Radar – We’ve been working with Agility Health Radar to develop support for Disciplined Agile Delivery, Disciplined Agile IT (DAIT), and Disciplined Agile Enterprise (DAE) assessments. See a video with Scott Ambler describing what the DAD radar addresses.
- Blueprint – Blueprint is an agile requirements tool for teams working at scale (particularly geographically distributed teams, teams in regulatory environments, or teams facing a complex domain). BUT, it does have explicit support for DA process definition.
- The Enterprise Transformation Advisor – The Enterprise Transformation Advisor is the industries’ only platform that supports transitioning to modern practice at enterprise scale, with innovative capability for Self-Organization, Inspect & Adapt and Value Stream Governance.
- IBM Rational Method Composer (RMC) – A web-based process definition and sharing tool. Supports the initial version of DAD, published about a year before the DAD book (which we consider to be the v1.o baseline). So call it DAD v0.5.
- MethodPark Stages – A web-based process definition and sharing tool.
- Microsoft TFS – There is a DAD template available for TFS 2013. The GITHub project is here and this blog posting (in Italian) describes it.
This list is not complete. If you know of a tool that includes explicit support for the DA decision process framework, please add a comment to this page so that we can capture it. Thank you very much.
Does Scale Affect Tooling Choices?
Yes. The following diagram summarizes the six scaling factors of tactical agility at scale. When a team faces one or more of these scaling factors they generally need more sophisticated tooling to help them do so. The following table explores how each scaling factor may affect your tooling choices. It is assumed that fundamental tools such as developer IDEs, continuous integration (CI), configuration management (CM), automated testing, and so on have been adopted by the team.
|Scaling Factor||Possible Tooling Needs|